Hawaii’s latest attempt to legalize casino gambling has been put on the back burner, as state legislators voted to indefinitely defer Senate Bill 893, effectively halting discussions on legalizing casinos in the state. The proposed legislation would establish regulated casino gaming within the Aloha Stadium Entertainment District and the Hawaii Convention Center. However, mounting criticisms scuttled its chances of success.
The Legislation Envisioned Comprehensive Reforms
Senate Bill 893 would have legalized casino gaming in Hawaii, one of only two states in the United States, the other being Utah, that bans all types of gambling. The legislation proposed the creation of the Hawaii Gaming Control Commission to oversee casino operations. It also envisioned a 15% tax on casino gross receipts to support education, public safety, and gambling addiction services.
The bill pledged to establish strict regulatory mechanisms to manage casino operations and minimize potential risks. Supporters also pointed out that regulated gambling would generate significant tax revenues, promote tourism, and create jobs. However, the proposal quickly became a lightning rod for controversy as critics griped about social harm, crime, and gambling addiction.
A hearing by the Senate Economic Development and Tourism Committee sealed the bill’s fate as the Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs, the Department of the Attorney General, and the Honolulu Prosecuting Attorney’s Office harshly criticized the proposed legislation, fearing a potential rise in such as fraud, money laundering, and organized crime, as well as the potential spoke in gambling harm.
Gambling in Hawaii Lacks Significant Support
Key figures like Senator Kurt Fevella voted against the bill, warning against permitting casinos at family-friendly venues and encroaching upon spaces traditionally used for community events such as sports tournaments and high school graduation ceremonies. State Senator Lynn DeCoite, another key voice against the bill, echoed the overall negative sentiment against the project.
“Casino gambling has not always been a favorite subject. Regardless if we are flying to Vegas or any other place, we’ve always had our challenges here in Hawaii.”
State Senator Lynn DeCoite
DeCoite recognized that many Hawaiians already travel to other states to gamble. However, she focused on the potential unintended adverse effects of introducing casinos to the state. Many residents and advocacy groups have also traditionally opposed gambling expansion in the state, noting it could lead to addiction, financial loss, and social polarization.
Hawaii has a long history of unsuccessful gambling bills. Previous attempts, like SB1569 and SB1507, also faced legislative roadblocks as continued resistance from legislators and community groups suggests that casino gambling will not be coming to Hawaii anytime soon. At least for now, the state remains committed to prioritizing community values, social welfare, and economic feasibility over projected gaming revenues.
